Direct-Acting vs Pilot-Operated Pressure Reducing Regulators

Operating Principle

Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators use the downstream pressure directly to balance the mechanical force of a spring acting on a diaphragm or piston. If the outlet pressure exceeds the set point, the diaphragm moves and reduces the flow, throttling the valve. Conversely, when the downstream pressure decreases, the spring pushes the diaphragm to open the valve and increase flow. All control is done locally on the main valve. Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators, on the other hand, use a smaller pilot valve that senses the downstream pressure and controls the main valve. The pilot valve regulates the control pressure that acts on the diaphragm or piston of the main valve, causing it to open or close proportionally. This design separates the function of the main valve from direct fluctuations in downstream pressure, allowing for more precise control.

Accuracy and Stability

Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators typically provide adequate control at lower flows and moderate pressure drops, but can exhibit some pressure drop with varying flow requirements. They are also more sensitive to vibration and rapid pressure changes, which can cause oscillation or instability. Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators offer significantly improved accuracy, stability, and sensitivity due to their design, especially at higher flows or under fluctuating downstream conditions. The pilot valve provides a feedback mechanism that allows the main valve to respond smoothly and maintain a more consistent output pressure.

Flow Capacity

Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators typically handle smaller flow capacities. The size of the main valve and the strength of the internal spring limit its ability to maintain stable pressure control at high flow rates. Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators are suited to high-flow applications because the pilot mechanism can efficiently modulate a large main valve without the need for heavy mechanical springs. This makes them ideal for industrial systems with significant pressure drops and large volumes.

Size and Complexity

Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators are typically simpler, more compact, and easier to service because they have fewer components. Their simple mechanical design makes troubleshooting and repairs easier. Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators are more complex and include a pilot valve, pilot tubing, and additional internal channels. This complexity can lead to higher initial investment and maintenance costs, but is justified in applications requiring high accuracy and capacity.

Applications

• Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators are commonly used in:
  • Low and medium pressure gas distribution systems
  • Laboratory equipment
  • Residential gas regulators
  • Low flow pneumatic circuits
• Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators are preferred in:
  • Industrial gas and steam systems with high flow rates
  • Process control where accurate pressure control is critical
  • Applications with large pressure fluctuations or large downstream volumes

---

Summary Table

Function	Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators	Pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators
How it works	Mechanical spring vs. downstream pressure equalization	Pilot valve controls main valve via control pressure
Accuracy and stability	Moderate, may cause pressure drop	High accuracy and stability
Flow capacity	Low to medium	Medium to high
Complexity and maintenance	Simple, easy to maintain	More complex, requires maintenance
Typical applications	Residential, laboratory, low flow	Industrial, high flow, critical control

---

Conclusion

The choice between a direct-acting or pilot-operated pressure reducing regulator depends primarily on the application's flow capacity, pressure stability requirements, and budget. Direct-acting pressure reducing regulators are suited to simpler, lower-flow systems, while pilot-operated pressure reducing regulators are well-suited to large, high-performance industrial environments where accuracy and robustness are critical.

By understanding these key differences, engineers and maintenance professionals can ensure optimum pressure control, tailored to their system needs.

 

Need the Right Pressure Reducing Regulator? Get Expert Help Selecting the Ideal Regulator Engineered for Performance |

Cashco’s pressure reducing regulators are designed for precise pressure control across a wide range of industrial applications—delivering reliability, safety, and efficiency. For more information about Cashco's regulators, view all models here .

Cashco is dedicated to ensuring you select the best solution for your tank protection needs. Need help choosing the right pressure reducing regulator? Contact us and our experienced team will gladly assist you in finding the ideal product!